Current:Home > MarketsChina lends billions to poor countries. Is that a burden ... or a blessing?-LoTradeCoin
China lends billions to poor countries. Is that a burden ... or a blessing?
View Date:2024-12-23 21:47:51
Chinese leaders have often boasted about their country's "miracle" progress in alleviating poverty and indicated their willingness to share their expertise with other nations.
Take its "Belt and Road Initiative," also known as the New Silk Road. China has spent nearly one trillion dollars in the last decade building highways, railways, ports and energy plants from east Asia to Europe in a bid to boost global trade.
But development experts who monitor such programs have long said that there's a catch – that China burdens countries with unsustainable debt as it asks for repayment and that it leaves human rights abuses in its wake.
Maybe the critics are wrong?
Now a major new survey looks at how countries view their participation in China's development projects. The finding challenges critics who say that countries have an overall negative experience. And of course ... it's a bit controversial.
AidData, a research lab at William & Mary University, surveyed 7,000 leaders in public, private and civil society sectors in over 140 countries. They asked participants to score the progress of various goals such as economic stability, security, public services and employment.
Lead report author Samantha Custer tells NPR that leaders with China as a development partner felt more optimistic across the board than countries that did not work with China. These China aid recipients were more likely to agree that their country had made progress on government accountability, physical security and social inclusion.
"Leaders often say they like that China is very quick to deliver financing and assistance," Custer explains. "For newly elected leaders when they need to deliver promises quickly, China is a preferred partner [compared to Western ones] because there is not as much red tape."
But does the survey ring true?
Others in the sector are skeptical of the participants' ability to be candid.
John Calabrese, director of the Middle East-Asia Project at the Middle East Institute wonders if taking leaders' answers at face value may give a misleading picture.
"I would guess at least some Middle East and North African [MENA] officials would not wish to air any problems or dissatisfaction with China lest this compromise their relationship," he says.
Custer says that the participants were afforded various levels of anonymity, but she cannot exclude the possibility that some may have felt intimidated.
But she believes there may be other theories for the reports of optimism. Perhaps these countries may have a lower expectation for internal reform or may find that projects work well "despite, rather than because of, China's contributions."
Calabrese added that certain features of the Chinese model may appeal to the leaderships of some countries, such as non-interference in other country's domestic affairs. A 2022 report by Arab Barometer – a non-partisan research network – revealed that China remains more popular across the MENA region than the United States.
Another possibility raised by critics: Maybe it's just too soon for countries to draw meaningful conclusions about the impact of the substantial outpouring of Chinese aid. According to AidData, China has recently disbursed billions in emergency loans. About 60% has gone to already-indebted low-income countries.
"We know that China is very opaque about the terms of its assistance," Custer says. "They will include in lending contracts explicit non-disclosure clauses prohibiting the lender from saying how much was borrowed and under what terms."
In 2019, China funded one out of every five infrastructure projects worth over $50 million in Africa. That's slightly less than the amount funded by African governments. Joseph Asunka, CEO of the pan-African research institution Afrobarometer, says that in terms of broad development partnerships, the U.S. (which historically reserves a quarter of its foreign assistance for Africa) gave $7.65 billion to Africa in 2021) and China come "neck and neck" in terms of positive perceptions across the continent.
"The majority of people express concern about the amount of money their government is borrowing from China," Asunka continues, "but the mitigating factor is when they see the infrastructure projects realized — a highway near their town, for example — and cheap and accessible Chinese goods like mobile phones."
But Asunka underscores that this changes when the subject of Chinese negative employment practices is raised. "The more violence perpetrated," Asunka says, "the more China's image begins to diminish."
In April a court in Rwanda sentenced a Chinese national to 20 years in prison for tying two of his local employees to a tree and whipping them. The Business & Human Rights Resource Centre watchdog recorded 181 human rights abuse allegations linked to Chinese business conduct in Africa between 2013 and 2020. Asunka says that most African stakeholders are in favor of conditions that would drive the growth of democracy and accountable governance, stipulations not usually associated with Chinese aid.
Ultimately, says AidData's Custer, China is still the financier of first resort when it comes to major infrastructure projects, but with the assistance of other partners, low-resource countries can strive to be more resilient when negotiating the terms.
"There is a role for Western democracies to play in addressing and curbing some of negative by-products of Chinese projects by improving internal systems to reduce corruption. It's not to say that countries shouldn't borrow from China, it's about doing so responsibly."
Andrew Connelly is a British freelance journalist focusing on politics, migration and conflict. He tweets @connellyandrew
veryGood! (3871)
Related
- Lady Gaga Joins Wednesday Season 2 With Jenna Ortega, So Prepare to Have a Monster Ball
- Alabama inmate Kenneth Smith poised to be test subject for new execution method, his lawyers say
- Supreme Court denies Alabama's bid to use GOP-drawn congressional map in redistricting case
- Greece is planning a major regularization program for migrants to cope with labor crunch
- Martha Stewart playfully pushes Drew Barrymore away in touchy interview
- Taylor Swift is a fan and suddenly, so is everyone else. Travis Kelce jersey sales jump nearly 400%
- House GOP prepares four spending bills as shutdown uncertainty grows
- California education chief Tony Thurmond says he’s running for governor in 2026
- 'Wheel of Fortune' contestant makes viral mistake: 'Treat yourself a round of sausage'
- Kerry Washington Details Decision to Have an Abortion in Her 20s
Ranking
- Businesses at struggling corner where George Floyd was killed sue Minneapolis
- Man jailed while awaiting trial for fatal Apple store crash because monitoring bracelet not charged
- Searchers find body believed to be that of a woman swept into ocean from popular Washington beach
- 21 New York Comic-Con Packing Essentials for Every Type of Fan
- Veterans face challenges starting small businesses but there are plenty of resources to help
- Costco now offering virtual medical care for $29
- Not again. Federal workers who’ve weathered past government shutdowns brace for yet another ordeal
- JPMorgan to pay $75 million to victims' fund as part of Jeffrey Epstein settlement
Recommendation
-
Rare Alo Yoga Flash Sale: Don’t Miss 60% Off Deals With Styles as Low as $5
-
Cars are a major predator for wildlife. How is nature adapting to our roads?
-
Survivor host Jeff Probst previews season 45 and reveals what makes a great player
-
Bruce Willis' Daughter Scout Honors Champion Emma Heming Willis Amid His Battle With FTD
-
Patricia Heaton criticizes media, 'extremists' she says 'fear-mongered' in 2024 election
-
Lionel Messi in limbo ahead of Inter Miami's big US Open Cup final. Latest injury update
-
Did Taylor Swift put Travis Kelce 'on the map'? TikTok trend captures hilarious reactions
-
Latino charitable giving rates drop sharply — but that’s not the full story